2025-02-18

The review process took a long time.
First submission received feedback for revision:
Revise 4th Feb 24
Manuscript submitted 5th Nov 23
After three rounds of revisions, accepted by AIP on Jan 9th, 25.

2024-03-05

June 2023: Submitted for review.
October 2023: Received reviews, one positive and one negative. Appeal successful.
December 2023: Submitted for second review.
March 2024: Received second review with five reviewers this time. Original reviewers split, new reviewers two positive and one negative. Editor decides to reject the manuscript.
The chaotic and lengthy review process increased my understanding of peer review but also left me with PTSD

2024-01-29

Quite fast

2024-01-28

Overall, the review process started quickly, but it feels like the wait time after acceptance is longer (possibly due to the Christmas and New Year holidays

2023-06-01

24-05-2023 manuscript submitted
25-05-2023 manuscript received
26-05-2023 editor assigned
26-05-2023 manuscript under consideration

2022-04-06

What happened afterwards?

2021-12-30

It is generally believed that the title and keywords complement each other around the research topic

2021-12-30

Keywords should be avoided in the title. Most journals have this recommendation

2021-12-27

The relationship between keywords and titles is crucial in determining the success of a piece of content. Keywords serve as a guide for search engines to properly index and rank content, while titles act as the first impression for users to determine if the content is relevant to their search. By accurately incorporating keywords into the title, content creators can increase visibility and attract the right audience

2021-12-26

Can the keywords be extracted from the title?